The Puzzles of Handedness

Handedness

Cari Neirenberg has an interesting article about left-handedness.

The truth is we know little about why people prefer to use one hand over another, and it’s unique to humans to have a large right-handed majority. In the animal world, there are roughly equal numbers who prefer their left paw to their right.

Most of the material in the article is taken from the book The Puzzle of Left-Handedness. 

As a left-hander, I’ve always felt that right handers over-estimate the uniqueness of being left-handed. However, there’s some interesting research that suggests your handedness affects how you learn and perceive your environment. 

For example, there’s a line of research that suggests our observational learning is increased when the person we’re observing has the same handedness as we do. This is intuitive to me, since there’s less processing for our brain to translate someone else’s movements into our own. 

(Random thought: I’m thinking of taking martial arts classes at the beginning of the year….maybe I should take the handedness of my instructor into consideration?)

Our handedness also affects our emotional affiliations. Left-handed people are more likely to make positive attributions to items simply because they appear on their left side. Ditto for right-handers. In controlled experiments this has consistently been the case, but “natural experiments” that map out spontaneous movements show the same result.

A cute example is a paper that studied the hand gestures of presidents during the debates. Dubya and John Kerry are both right-handed, and Obama and McCain are both left-handed. The researchers graphed their gestures against “good concepts” and “bad concepts” to see if there was a correlation. Here’s the result:

Speakers associate positive messages more strongly with dominant hand gestures and negative messages with non-dominant hand gestures, revealing a hidden link between action and emotion. This pattern cannot be explained by conventions in language or culture, which associate ‘good’ with ‘right’ but not with ‘left’; rather, results support and extend the body-specificity hypothesis.

The full text of the paper is here. 

I don’t know of any research that studies this particularly, but I’d be interested to see if non-dominant bodily gestures correlate with lying and truth-telling.

1 thought on “The Puzzles of Handedness”

  1. Interesting post. The part about right-handers over rating the uniqueness of being left handed is funny because my brother is left handed and he’s always talking about how remarkable it makes him. I’m right handed and I’ve always thought he was exaggerating. Glad to see someone agrees with me!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s