Greens Powders, Meal Replacement Powders, and Whole Food Vitamins: Do You Need All Three?

This comment was recently posted on my review of All Day Energy Greens:

 i started drinking garden of life raw meal replacement. if you get a chance can you review that? i just got started on green plant drinl last week and i don’t know if this is good choice for me. thanks

And I recently received this email asking about different Greens powders:

I am currently looking at “The Ultimate Meal, Green Vibrance, Garden of LifeRaw Food, and a few others

Perhaps this warrants a more detailed discussion between these different types of supplements.

Vegan meal powders like Garden of Life Raw Food and Vega One are not the same thing as greens powders like Incredible Greens or Vitamineral Green, which are different still from whole food vitamins like MegaFood or New Chapter whole food multivitamins.

They serve fairly functions but have important differences between their macronutrient profile, cost, and potential benefits.

meal replacement shake

a meal replacement shake: worth the additional cost?

Meal Replacement Powders

Meal replacement powders are intended to be just that……something you can use in place of a meal.  To perform this function they’ll typically have a combination of all the different macronutrients, a calorie count between 150-300, and an ingredient list that’ll comprise of protein, fat, fiber, carbohydrate, greens, and berries.

They were traditionally used by bodybuilders looking to gain weight, but have recently become popular with the vegan/raw /vegetarian crowd as a way to combine several supplements into one.  Popular brands from the latter category include Vega One, Shakeology, Garden of Life Raw Meal, NOW Foods vegan shake, and Amazing Grass Amazing Meal.

They’ll typically be more expensive than greens powders and vitamins, with a cost that’ll typically run anywhere from $40-$120.

By weight, meal replacement powders usually have a macronutrient breakdown that’ll look something like this:

Protein: 60%

Fiber: 10%

Greens: 15%

Berries: 5%

Fats: 5%

Of course your particular brand of meal replacement powder will vary.  The best ones will also have probiotics, digestive enzymes, and a fatty acid profile that’ll consist of mostly omega-3 essential fatty acids.

In my opinion here are the biggest strengths and weaknesses of these supplements:

The Good:

They’re a convenient way to combine multiple supplements into one, and they’re the most satisfying to eat. The fat and protein give them a rich, fulfilling taste and they satisfy hunger in ways that multivitamins and greens powders cannot.

They’re best for post-workout nutrition, people looking for a healthy snack at work or on the road, or people looking to consolidate the supplements they currently take.

I know when I  was at my old 9-5 I regularly made a shake after lunch and it helped with my hunger and overall

The Bad:

They can get pretty expensive.  “Premium” meal replacement powders can cost up to $100, and this price is primarily for a nutrient (protein) that most people already get more than enough of and is fairly cheap to manufacture.  I’ve written before how the majority of people do not need to worry about getting enough protein.

greens powder

greens powders: a supplement I’m partial to

Greens Powders

Greens powders condense different green vegetables, sea algaes, medicinal herbs, grasses, and other therapeutic green foods into one powder.

Their purpose is to primarily rejuvenate the body, “grease the wheels” of your metabolic systems, and give your body a cocktail of different phytonutrients and antioxidants that would otherwise be very difficult to get in your day to day diet.

The contents of a greens powder will often provide a variety of different vitamins and minerals, but most are not specifically designed to provide the grocery list of vitamins A, B, C, etc. in the precise amounts that you’re accustomed to reading on the back of a vitamin label.

They may also help reduce your appetite and feel more full throughout the day, but intentionally lack the bloat of a meal replacement powder.

Greens powders embrace the idea of metabolic diversity.  The concept that it’s not merely the nutrients in isolation that provide benefits to your body, but the delicate complex that they come delivered in which work synergistically to exert a level of metabolic control not possible with vitamins alone.

Their core ingredients tend to be more expensive than the other two types of supplements, and usually have smaller serving sizes than meal replacement powders.   Their prices are typically lower than meal replacement powders but are usually more expensive on a $$/oz basis.

The Good

Provide the most valuable nutrients in the most viable form compared to the other two supplements, will often provide health benefits that are the hardest to replicate.

The Bad

Often taste bad, most expensive on a per ounce basis,  and the sheer diversity of ingredients you can put into a greens powder makes it more difficult to decipher the differences in quality between products.

For clarity on choosing one read my superfood powder buying guide.

whole food vitamins

whole food vitamins: better than the regular….but more expensive

Whole Food Multivitamins

The whole food multivitamin is a twist on the most tried and true supplement in the world: the multivitamin.  However,  a large problem with multivitamins is that the majority of their nutrients come in a form that’s poorly digested and possibly even detrimental to your health.  The whole food vitamin improves on this weakness by using the broth and extracts of whole foods to get the Vitamin A, B, C, E, etc to put in the pill.

The nutrients in a whole food vitamin are the most processed and therefore least likely to have the greatest impact, but are very likely to have a higher absorbance than the traditional vitamin.  Lots of people are just more accustomed to pills than powders, so many will find the form to be beneficial.

The Good

A definite improvement over a traditional multivitamin, easier to take and digest, the most complete list of vitamins and minerals, cheaper on a per-serving basis than the other two options.

The Bad

More expensive than regular vitamins, more processed than a greens or meal replacement powder, the benefits stem more from theory than conclusive evidence, many pills are often required for one serving.

The Big Question: Which One Should I Get?

So all three of these supplements are a little bit the same and a little bit different.  Do you need one? Two? All three?

Let me begin by making the most important observation: it’s absolutely not necessary to always buy all three of these.  The marginal value of these groups of supplements falls very quickly after you buy the first one. They are complimentary, but for $100-$150 a month you’ll likely have a higher return just buying healthier groceries.

Each supplement covers about 2/3 of what the others do, so it’s mostly a matter of what’s most important to you.

In general I’d group the biggest advantage of the three like this:

Meal Shakes: supplement consolidation, satiety, food replacement

Greens powders: wellness, rejuvenation, micronutrients

Food Based Vitamins: least expensive, easiest to take, simplest way to make sure your bases are covered

Choose the one that’s most important to you, then look at what you have leftover and decide if the differences between the other and what you don’t have is worth the extra money spent.

If you want to know what take…….it’s a greens powder.  But of course anyone who reads this blog regularly will know what my biases are.  So caveat emptor.

A Handy Comparison Table

For the infovores out there, here’s a condensed comparison among the different products.

Type
Price Range
Form
Best for....
Biggest Weakness
Reference Materials
Jonathan's Favorite
Meal Replacement Powder$40-$130Powdersnacks, consolidating supplements, post workout nutritionexpensive, pay a lot for protein, high caloric count makes it impractical for someThe Unofficial Plant Protein Supplement Buying GuideVega One
Greens Powders$20-$75Powderholistic wellness, rejuvenation, detoxificationtaste bad, expensive per ounce, most narrow of the supplementsThe Superfood Powder Buying GuideToo many to list :)
Whole Food Vitamins$20-$40Tabletcovering your basesleast absorbance, fewest peripheral benefitssynthetic vs natural, vitamin buying guidemega food

Turbocharge Your Body With 38 Different Superfoods

  • Raw, Unprocessed, and Non-GMO
  • Grass Juices That Alkalize Your Body
  • Medicinal Herbs That Revitalize Your Immune System
  • Adaptogens That Increase Your Energy
  • Probiotics That Aid Digestion And Detoxification
incredible greens

What Others Have To Say

---So What Are You Waiting For?---

About Jonathan Bechtel

Owner of Health Kismet, maker of Incredible Greens, a green superfood supplement that combines 35 different raw greens, herbs, probiotics, grasses and fruits into a sweet tasting powder.

Comments

  1. Hey Jonathan

    Great post! Thanks for sharing your expertise on meal replacement powders; I was always wondering about how effective those were.

    Btw, check your support inbox; I sent you an email earlier this week.

  2. Hi Jonathan – thanks for the reply! I’ve actually sent the email twice; once 7 days a go and once 3 days ago. I’ll leave the brief email here (feel free to delete it after you read it):

    Hey Jonathan

    I love your articles on Health Kismet about creating a supplement business! I’ve been wanting to start my own for the last year, but didn’t know where to start so I put it on the back burner.

    You said you were able to start your company for $3000; can you show me exactly how to do the same? I’m most interested in learning how you decided on which manufacturers / dropshippers to use.

    Of course, I’d be willing to pay you (let me know how much), and I’m ready to start now! Feel free to contact me via email. And if you are not interested in coaching me, could you please point me in the right direction of where I can find dropshippers?

    Thanks for taking the time to read this, and I look forward to hearing from you!

    • Jonathan Bechtel says:

      Jeff,

      I just sent you an email. I also deleted the last part of this comment which had your personal information.

  3. Thank you for the great information. I recently received a feeding tube. I am 62 and will use it for the rest of my life. I am very active, ride a bike 12 miles a day and work out in a fitness center daily. Humana gave me Ensure to live off the rest of my life. After reading the label on back, I said no way. I will make it on my own. Thanks again for the info.

  4. Okay which one is for weight loss I want to lose weight but I don’t have the time to cook or juice in all of that I just need something I can replace my three meals a day and maybe six meals in a day or do something where I can monitor and regulate my eating

  5. Bong torregoza says:

    Thanks for sharing now I start my greens powder
    Bong

  6. Bong torregoza says:

    Jonathan what is the best greens you know thanks

Leave a Reply